Uncovering the Decisions Behind “All in the Family’s” Rise to Iconic Status

By: Lauren Wurth | Published: Sep 03, 2023

For 8 years, from 1971 to 1979, Americans tuned in every week to watch “”All in the Family,” the iconic comedy created by Norman Lear. The show made viewers laugh with Archie Bunker’s antics and tackled serious social issues, making it a household name. 

But what kept audiences hooked and helped the show reach the top were 30 behind-the-scenes decisions, some of which nearly caused it to sink. From the casting of Rob Reiner to the controversial storylines, find out how these decisions made “All in the Family” an undeniable classic.

Revealing the Secrets Behind “All in the Family's” Transformation into a Classic 

Before “All in the Family” became an iconic TV show, it had a rocky start. Initially, the show was set to air on ABC, even after two attempts the executives weren’t impressed with the pilot episodes. 


Source: Ron Eisenberg/Michael Ochs Archives/Getty Images

However, the production company had the wisdom to sell the rights to CBS, paving the way for one of the greatest sitcoms of all time. Discover the secrets behind “All in the Family’s” transformation into a classic, from the initial sale to the key decisions made behind the scenes.

CBS President's Bold Move - The Rural Purge of 1970 

In 1970, CBS’s new president Robert Wood made a radical move. He wanted to bring more socially relevant programming to the network and attract younger viewers. As a result, he axed several comedies like Petticoat Junction and Green Acres, a move that came to be known as ‘The Rural Purge’. 


Source: Bettmann/Getty Images

This bold move allowed for shows like “All in the Family” to become a household name. With this radical move, CBS was able to stay ahead of the game in the world of television.

The Inspiration Behind "All in the Family" - The BBC Classic Till Death Us Do Part 

Norman Lear’s classic sitcom “All in the Family” was heavily influenced by the BBC’s “Till Death Us Do Part.” The British comedy centered around a prejudiced man who was not afraid to share his views with the family. Sound familiar? This classic show was the inspiration for the beloved “All in the Family,” which went on to become one of the most popular sitcoms of the 1970s. 


Source: Leonard Burt/Getty Images

With its unique blend of comedy and social commentary, it’s no wonder it was such a hit. Thanks to the BBC’s “Till Death Us Do Part,” “All in the Family” was born, and continues to be remembered as a television classic.

Rejected Pilots Lead to TV Icon 

When the creators of “All in the Family” first pitched their show, it was rejected twice by ABC. The original pilot was called “Justice For All,” which sounded more like a courtroom drama than a sitcom. Their second attempt was called “Those Were the Days,” which still failed to spark the interest of ABC executives. 


Source: Tandem Productions/Sony Pictures Television

It wasn’t until CBS bought the show and gave it its iconic title that “All in the Family” gained its rightful place in TV history. From its humble beginnings to its iconic status, “All in the Family” is one of the most beloved sitcoms of all time.

Archie Justice? How the Iconic Character Almost Got a Different Name

Have you ever wondered why Archie Bunker’s last name is Bunker? It turns out that in the original pilot, the beloved character was actually named “Archie Justice!” His last name was even printed on his doormat, as a play on his bigoted ways. While it may have been clever, it was ultimately deemed too on the nose. 

Source: Michael Ochs Archives/Getty Images

Thankfully, in the next version of the pilot, Archie’s last name was changed to the iconic Bunker. It’s hard to imagine “All in the Family” without Archie Bunker, but this could have been a reality had the showrunners not changed his name!


“All in the Family's” Iconic Theme Song - A Musical Masterpiece Crafted by Two Legends 

“All in the Family’s” theme song is an iconic part of the show’s legacy, but few people know the true story of how it came to be. Lyricist Lee Adams and composer Charles Strouse are the masterminds behind this musical masterpiece, two legends with quite some pedigree. 

Source: Amy Sussman/Getty Images

Not only did they create the iconic “All in the Family” theme song, but they also composed for the well-known musicals “Bye Bye Birdie” and “Annie.” The show’s unforgettable theme song is a testament to Adams and Strouse’s brilliance and continues to be remembered as a classic.


“All in the Family's” Iconic Theme Song - From Orchestral Rendition to Last Resort Off-Key Duet 

The iconic theme song of “All in the Family” almost never happened. Producers couldn’t find the money for an orchestral rendition of the song Those Were the Days, and it seemed like the show would have to go without a theme song. As a last resort, Carroll O’Connor and Jean Stapleton, who played Archie and Edith respectively, stepped in to sing an off-key duet. 

Source: Ron Galella/Ron Galella Collection via Getty Images

Thankfully, this off-key rendition of the classic song ended up becoming the iconic theme song of “All in the Family.” It’s a testament to the show’s charm that this last-resort version became one of the most recognizable theme songs in TV history.


The Surprising Success of “All in the Family's” Closing Theme - "Remembering You" 

Carroll O’Connor’s involvement with “All in the Family” extended beyond just acting. He was also the co-writer of the show’s closing theme song Remembering You, and ended up receiving royalties from it. Surprisingly, the lyrics he penned never ended up being used on the show!

Source: Bettmann/Getty Images

 Nevertheless, Remembering You proved to be a success and remains a beloved song to this day. It’s a testament to O’Connor’s talent and the show’s popularity that this closing theme was able to become a success, even without the actor’s lyrics.


Casting Archie Bunker - How a Liberal Actor Became an Iconic Character 

When showrunners were casting for “All in the Family,” they knew they needed the right person to play Archie Bunker: the blue-collar, cigar-smoking family man who always knew the wrong thing to say. Surprisingly, they chose Carroll O’Connor, a liberal actor for the role. 

Source: Bettmann/Getty Images

While this may have seemed like an odd fit, O’Connor’s strong acting abilities helped him make the character come to life. Thanks to his performance, Archie Bunker became an iconic character and one of the most beloved TV characters of all time.


Mickey Rooney Rejects Iconic Role - How Norman Lear Found Archie Bunker 

When Norman Lear was casting for “All in the Family,” he originally wanted Mickey Rooney to play Archie Bunker. Rooney, however, was apparently uncomfortable with the role and agreed with critics that Archie was too controversial. As a result, he rejected the part and Norman Lear was forced to look elsewhere.

Source: United Artists/Getty Images

Thankfully, Lear eventually found Carroll O’Connor, who was perfect for the role. Thanks to O’Connor’s performance, Archie Bunker became an iconic character and one of the most beloved TV characters of all time.


Casting the Liberal Characters - How "All in the Family" Found Its Iconic Duo

Casting the liberal characters in “All in the Family” proved to be quite the challenge. Before Rob Reiner and Sally Struthers were ultimately cast as Michael and Gloria, executives tried out two other pairs: Kelly Jean Peter and Tim MacIntire, and Candy Azzara and Chip Oliver. 

Source: Tandem Productions

Thankfully, Reiner and Struthers were eventually cast and became the iconic duo that fans know and love. With their unique chemistry, it’s no wonder that these two actors were able to bring the characters of Michael and Gloria to life.


Penny Marshall Almost Earned Iconic Role

Penny Marshall was almost cast as the iconic Gloria in the beloved sitcom “All in the Family.” However, producers felt that Sally Struthers and Carroll O’Connor shared a familial resemblance that made them more suitable for the role. 

Source: Bettmann/Getty Images

Despite this disappointment, Marshall went on to achieve success as the star of the spin-off series Laverne and Shirley. Marshall’s legacy will forever be remembered for her contribution to television history.


Harrison Ford Considered for Iconic Role in "All in the Family" 

Believe it or not, Harrison Ford was once considered for the role of Michael Stivic in the classic sitcom “All in the Family.” The part eventually went to Rob Reiner, but studio executives initially reached out to the future Han Solo star in an attempt to lure him to the project. 

Source: Lucasfilm/Sunset Boulevard/Corbis via Getty Images

Unfortunately, Ford found the character of Archie Bunker too offensive, so he declined the offer. Despite this, the show remains a beloved classic and Reiner’s performance as Michael is remembered fondly by fans.


Proudly Recorded in Front of a Live Studio Audience 

Norman Lear was determined to keep the authenticity of “All in the Family” intact, so he refused to incorporate laugh tracks into the show. Instead, each episode was recorded on tape before a live studio audience, giving viewers a true-to-life experience. 

Source: H. Armstrong Roberts/ClassicStock/Getty Images

This was something Lear was so proud of, that he made sure to include a special note at the end of each episode: “All in the Family was recorded on tape before a live studio audience.” This is just one of the many reasons why the show remains a classic today.


CBS Braces for Controversy Ahead of "All in the Family" Premiere 

When CBS was preparing to air the “All in the Family” pilot, the network executives were understandably worried about the potentially offensive material. In anticipation of a viewer backlash, the network set up a huge team of operators to man the phone lines.

Source: Tandem Productions

Fortunately, the episode was a hit with viewers and “All in the Family” went on to become one of the most beloved sitcoms of all time.


CBS Braces for Complaints, But Receives Little Resistance

As “All in the Family’s” pilot episode was about to air, CBS was understandably worried about the potentially controversial material. In an effort to defuse any potential viewer backlash, the network added in a disclaimer at the beginning of the episode.

Source: Bettmann/Getty Images

To the surprise of many, the phones at CBS didn’t ring off the hook with complaints. Audiences had accepted Archie Bunker’s brand of comedy. This reaction was a sign that “All in the Family” would become the beloved classic it is today.


Theme Song Causes Unexpected Trouble for Showrunners 

CBS was concerned that “All in the Family’s” controversial topics would cause a huge viewer backlash. However, it was the show’s theme song that ended up causing the most trouble. Despite the clear lyrics, many viewers had a difficult time understanding the last lines of the song.

Source: Tandem Productions

The calls about the muffled words became so numerous that the showrunners had to re-record the entire theme song. It’s amazing how such a seemingly small detail can have such an impact on a show!


Archie Bunker's Quips Inspired by Norman Lear's Parents 

Many of the hilarious and sometimes controversial quips uttered by Archie Bunker in the classic sitcom “All in the Family” were actually inspired by Norman Lear’s parents. Lear drew on his own family experiences to create the show, and two of Archie’s most memorable lines were uttered by his own parents. 

Source: Frederick M. Brown/Getty Images

His father famously told his mother to “stifle herself,” which was usually met with a response of “you are the laziest white man I ever saw.” It’s amazing how Lear was able to capture the humor and dynamic of his own family in his show.


Fans Miss the Point When They Call for Archie Bunker to be President 

Norman Lear wanted to make “All in the Family” with one goal in mind: to show that Archie Bunker was always wrong. Every episode featured someone correcting or reprimanding him, yet fans of the show grew to love Archie so much that they even called for him to be president.

Source: Bettmann/Getty Images

Although Lear was flattered by the show’s success, he couldn’t help but feel that his viewers had somewhat missed the point. Nevertheless, the show remains a classic and Archie Bunker an iconic character in television history.


Rob Reiner Gets a Hairpiece to Fix a Receding Hairline Issue 

When the first season of “All in the Family” aired, Rob Reiner had a problem. His receding hairline didn’t make him look like the cool, young guy he was supposed to be playing. In order to maintain his on-screen image, the producers stepped in and gave him a hairpiece. From then on, Reiner’s character, Michael ‘Meathead’ Stivic, had a full, thick head of hair. 

Source: Bettmann/Getty Images

While Reiner’s hairpiece was a solution to the problem, it caused a few issues of its own. He was constantly having to adjust it, and it caused some tension between him, and the writers and producers. Nevertheless, it served its purpose and allowed Reiner to continue playing his iconic role.


Norman Lear's Bold Offer to CBS Denied for "All in the Family" 

In the 1970s, the commercial time for “All in the Family” increased. This meant that each episode of the show lost three additional minutes to ads. This didn’t sit well with Norman Lear, the show’s creator. He decided to make a bold offer to CBS – he would pay them to give up the extra commercial slots. However, his offer was ultimately denied. 

Source: Jeff Kravitz/FilmMagic, Inc/Getty Images

Though Lear was unsuccessful in his bid, it showed his dedication to the show. He was willing to go above and beyond to ensure that it maintained its high quality and original run time. “All in the Family” went on to become one of the most beloved sitcoms of all time, so it’s safe to say that Lear’s efforts paid off.


Norman Lear Introduces “The Bottle Episode” 

Norman Lear was a revolutionary in the world of television. Not only did he create the beloved sitcom “All in the Family,” but he also introduced a new concept to the industry: the bottle episode. This term was used to describe episodes that took place on one or two sets, trapping the characters in the same setting. 

Source: Tandem Productions

The first example of this was in the episode Two’s a Crowd, when Archie and Michael get stuck in a bar’s storeroom. This episode not only provided viewers with a fresh and engaging experience, but it also saved the production a lot of money. It’s safe to say that Norman Lear’s innovation truly changed the TV industry.


Norman Lear Takes Inspiration From Akira Kurosawa's Rashomon 

When it comes to great minds in the entertainment industry, Norman Lear is one of the best. For the “All in the Family” episode Everybody Tells the Truth, Lear drew inspiration from the classic Akira Kurosawa film, “Rashomon.” Both stories feature flashbacks that offer different perspectives of the same incident. 

Source: John Springer Collection/Corbis via Getty Images

This episode of “All in the Family” showed Lear’s admiration for the greats of cinema. By incorporating elements of Kurosawa’s work, he was able to bring a unique blend of drama and comedy to the show. It was this type of innovation that made “All in the Family” one of the most beloved sitcoms of all time.


Vincent Gardenia Quits After One Season due to Boredom

“All in the Family” was known for its two feuding couples: the Bunkers and the Lorenzos. The Lorenzos were the Bunkers’ more liberal next-door neighbors, and were originally intended to be long-running characters. Betty Garrett portrayed Irene until 1975, but Vincent Gardenia only stayed on as Frank for one season.

Source: Jack Mitchell/Getty Images

It was reported that Gardenia quit the show due to boredom. He felt that his character was too one-dimensional, and he wanted to pursue other projects. His departure marked the end of the Lorenzo storyline, and the show went on to become a hit without him.


Carroll O'Connor Goes on Strike to Get His Wishes Met 

As “All in the Family” started to gain popularity, Carroll O’Connor demanded a new contract. He wanted 12 weeks of vacation time for a 24-week work schedule, and he wasn’t afraid to take a stand and go on strike. After some of his demands were met, he finally returned to the show. 

Source: Carlos Chavez/Los Angeles Times via Getty Images

It’s clear that O’Connor was determined to get what he wanted. His bold move showed his passion for the show, and it’s safe to say that “All in the Family” wouldn’t be the same without him.


Carroll O'Connor Needed Assurance Before Accepting Iconic Role

Carroll O’Connor was initially hesitant about accepting the role of Archie Bunker in “All in the Family.” He was living in Italy at the time, and he wanted reassurance that his flight home would be paid for if the show didn’t make it past the pilot stage. Fortunately the producers never had to fulfill their promise.

Source: Jack Mitchell/Getty Images

“All in the Family” went on to become one of the most beloved sitcoms of all time, and O’Connor’s portrayal of Archie Bunker was an iconic one. It’s a good thing he accepted the role in the first place.


"All in the Family" Introduces the First Gay Character on Television 

Only a couple of years after the Stonewall riots brought gay rights into the social consciousness, “All in the Family” made history. It was the first TV sitcom to feature a gay character, though the word “gay” was never mentioned. This episode made Archie Bunker flustered and uncomfortable.

Tandem Productions

Source: Tandem Productions

He was not used to seeing such flamboyant behavior, and it showed how far the show was willing to go in order to push boundaries. It was a bold move, and one that paved the way for more LGBT representation on television.


Shocking Glimpse of Nude Baby Leaves Viewers Outraged 

CBS was worried that many elements of “All in the Family” would offend viewers, but they probably didn’t expect the biggest outrage to come from one particular episode. In it, Gloria delivers a baby and the camera briefly captures the newborn’s bare skin. This glimpse of nudity was too much for some viewers and complaints soon started rolling in. 

Source: Tandem Productions

It was an unexpected moment that shocked viewers and left them outraged. Nevertheless, it was a sign of how far the show was willing to push boundaries in order to bring important issues to the forefront.


"All in the Family" Breaks Taboos with Emmy-Winning Episode About Menopause 

“All in the Family” was never afraid to tackle taboo topics, and Edith’s Problem was one of the most successful examples. In this episode, Edith accepts that she will go through menopause and expresses her frustration and anxiety to her husband, who gives it back to her in hefty supply.

Source: Bettmann/Getty Images

This episode was so powerful that Ben Styler, the writer, earned an Emmy for it. It was a bold move that showed the show’s commitment to tackling difficult issues and promoting social change.


Jean Stapleton Chooses "All in the Family" Over Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory 

In 1971, Jean Stapleton was presented with a difficult decision. She had the opportunity to play the role of Mrs. Teavee in the upcoming Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory. This meant she would have to leave “All in the Family” for several episodes, possibly a whole season!

Source: Silver Screen Collection/Getty Images

After careful consideration, Stapleton decided that she preferred portraying Edith Bunker. She declined the role in Willy Wonka, and her decision ultimately made “All in the Family” the success it is today. It’s safe to say that her decision was the right one.


"All in the Family" Takes on Vietnam War in Iconic Episode The Draft Dodger  

“All in the Family” was never one to shy away from controversial topics, and the Vietnam War was no exception. In the episode The Draft Dodger, Archie Bunker was put in the middle of the conflict. He hosted a Christmas dinner attended by a draft dodger, much to his chagrin. 

Source: Tandem Productions

This episode became iconic, as it showed how the show was willing to take on difficult topics in order to bring awareness to them. It was a bold move that made “All in the Family” one of the most beloved sitcoms of all time.


Archie Bunker Takes the Wheel: O'Connor's Vision for "All in the Family" Revived

In the early 1990s, Norman Lear tried to capture the success of “All in the Family” with a brand-new series. This time the focus would be on Archie Bunker, now a full-time cab driver and the topical conversations he would have with his passengers. However, Lear wasn’t convinced and decided instead to focus on developing 704 Hauser in 1994. 

Source: Brenda Chase/Getty Images

Fast forward to 2021, and O’Connor’s vision for “All in the Family” is being revived. Grab a seat, buckle up, and join Archie Bunker on an exciting new journey. With his timeless wit and charm, you can expect plenty of laughs and thought-provoking conversations as he takes you on a ride you won’t soon forget!


Breaking the Mold: Sally Struthers Dares to Take a Stand for Gloria Bunker 

Frustrated by the lack of development for her character, Gloria Bunker, Sally Struthers took a bold approach to get what she wanted. In 1974, she sued producers of “All in the Family” to break free from her contract. The tactic worked, and Struthers was given more to do. In the end she appeared in 157 episodes.

Source: Alberto E. Rodriguez/Getty Images

What makes this story truly remarkable is that Sally Struthers dared to challenge the status quo. She took a bold stand and refused to settle for what was given to her. Her boldness and courage paid off and she became an inspiration for many. If you’re ever feeling stuck, take a page from Sally Struthers’ book and dare to take a stand.


When the Rat Pack Met Archie Bunker: Sammy Davis Jr. Visits "All in the Family" 

Who is the most famous guest star to ever appear on “All in the Family?” None other than the legendary Sammy Davis Jr.! When the Rat Pack star visited the Bunker family, Archie Bunker put his foot in his mouth again and again, giving Sammy plenty of chances to hit back with his trademark wit. 

Source: Bettmann/Getty Images

But it wasn’t all animosity. Sammy even planted a kiss on Archie’s cheek! It’s a moment that will go down in TV history. From the tension between Sammy and Archie to the warm embrace between them, this one episode will leave you laughing, cringing, and feeling all the feels. Revisit a classic and join Sammy Davis Jr. on his unforgettable trip to “All in the Family.”


From Thrift Shop Finds to Icons: The "All in the Family" Chairs 

Take a Seat at the Smithsonian. Have you ever wondered what happened to the artifacts from “All in the Family?” Well, the two chairs Archie and Edith always sat in have been carefully preserved in the Smithsonian National Museum of American History in Washington, D.C.. Believe it or not, those chairs were actually purchased from a thrift shop prior to the pilot episode! 

Source: David/Flickr

Now the chairs have been immortalized by Norman Lear’s iconic sitcom, and they’ve taken a seat at the Smithsonian. From thrift shop finds to cultural icons, these chairs represent the timeless appeal of “All in the Family.” Visit the Smithsonian National Museum of American History and see these unforgettable pieces of TV history for yourself.


Maude Findlay Takes the Reins: The First "All in the Family" Spinoff Makes Its Mark

What was the first “All in the Family” spinoff? The honor goes to Bea Arthur who played Maude. The show featured Maude Findlay, Edith Bunker’s outspoken, liberal cousin. Much like the show it came from, Maude wasn’t afraid to tackle big issues. 

Source: Bettmann/Getty Images

Maude Findlay took the reins from “All in the Family” and made her mark in TV history. From her bold opinions to her sharp wit, Maude was a revolutionary character that helped to shape the TV landscape. Revisit this classic spinoff and join Maude on her trailblazing journey.


Norman Lear's Universe: The Spinoff That Changed TV Forever 

Before the Marvel Cinematic Universe, there was Norman Lear’s own television universe of “All in the Family.” This classic sitcom gave birth to more spin offs than any other show: Maude, The Jeffersons, Archie Bunker’s Place, Good Times, and more. In total, there were seven spin offs that were part of this universe! 

Source: FilmPublicityArchive/United Archives via Getty Images

Norman Lear’s universe of sitcoms left a lasting impression on TV and helped to shape the landscape for years to come. Revisit these beloved classics and join the characters on their journey. From Archie Bunker to Maude Findlay, there’s a story for everyone in this timeless universe.


Louise Takes the Leap: Isabel Sanford Moves to the Jeffersons in Search of a New Adventure 

Isabel Sanford wasn’t given a choice when it came to moving over to work on The Jeffersons. Producers told the actress that her character, Louise, was being taken out of “All in the Family,” no matter what she decided to do. That led to Sanford’s decision to take the leap and explore a new adventure. 

Source: Ron Galella/Ron Galella Collection via Getty Images

She was met with a new cast and, naturally, lots more backstage drama. But Sanford’s determination and courage paid off. Louise became one of the most beloved characters on The Jeffersons and her story will be remembered for years to come. Join Isabel Sanford on her daring journey and experience Louise’s transformation for yourself.


Two Decades Apart: Sanford and Hemsley's Age Gap on The Jeffersons

Sanford and Hemsley may have played husband and wife on The Jeffersons, but in real life, the pair were two decades apart. Sanford was born in 1917, while Hemsley had entered the world in 1938. But that wasn’t the only notable age gap on the show. Hemsley was just 11 years older than his on-screen son Mike Evans!

Source: Kevin Winter/Getty Images

It’s a fascinating fact that speaks to the power of Sanford and Hemsley’s performances. Despite their age difference, the pair managed to convincingly portray the loving Jeffersons. Join the Jeffersons on their iconic journey and experience the magic of Sanford and Hemsley for yourself.


Love & Hate Behind the Scenes: Sanford and Hemsley's Complicated Relationship on The Jeffersons 

As with many on-screen couples, the love wasn’t always there off-screen between the two stars of The Jeffersons. According to reports, Sanford was reportedly disappointed by how unattractive and small her TV husband was, and thought him to be overbearing. In return, Hemsley is said to have found Sanford rather full of herself. 

Source: Frank Micelotta/Getty Images

Despite their complicated relationship, Sanford and Hemsley managed to deliver convincing performances as the Jeffersons. Revisit this legendary sitcom and experience the love-hate relationship between the two stars for yourself. From comedic banter to heated arguments, it’s a journey you won’t soon forget.