Senate in Shambles Over Dress Code, of All Things

By: Georgia McKoy | Published: Oct 06, 2023

Senator John Fetterman from Pennsylvania found himself amidst a debate not typically seen in the U.S. Senate – a dispute concerning attire. This occurred when Senate Majority Leader Charles Schumer announced a relaxation of the Senate’s traditional dress code. 

The change, although unspoken, was perceived by many as a nod to accommodate Fetterman’s preference for less formal attire, such as sweatshirts, hoodies, and shorts.

Fetterman’s Attire Sparks Discussion

Senator Fetterman, who is known for his casual dress code, became the subject of conversation after the Senate’s dress code was relaxed.

Advertisement

Source: Getty Images

He was publicly scrutinized, not for his policy positions or legislative actions, but rather for his choice of clothing. The Senate’s decision to relax the dress code stirred a conversation that transcended the usual political discourse and entered into a cultural dialogue.

Advertisement

Bipartisan Opposition

The relaxed dress code was met with opposition from both sides of the aisle. Prominent figures, including Senator Joe Manchin, were reported to be in disapproval of the change. 

Advertisement

Source: Getty Images

This opposition culminated in a collective effort to review the relaxed standards. Schumer, who initially facilitated the relaxation of the dress code, acknowledged the overwhelming sentiment for a more formal dress code.

Reinstatement of Formal Attire

The Senate, within two weeks, unanimously agreed to reinstate a formal dress code, marking the end of the briefly instated casual wear era. 

Advertisement

Source: Getty Images

Senators Manchin and Romney introduced the measure that reinstated formal attire. Schumer expressed his appreciation for Fetterman’s cooperation during the process and commended the leadership of Manchin and Romney in addressing the issue.

International Commentary

The conversation surrounding Fetterman’s attire caught the attention of international commentators, including Toronto Star columnist Leanne Delap. 

Advertisement

Source: Getty Images

Delap likened Fetterman’s casual attire to that of taking out the garbage. The senator’s choice of clothing, although a domestic issue, resonated on an international scale, indicating the broad reach and impact of the conversation.

Fetterman’s Personal Brand

Fetterman’s preference for casual clothing is a well-known aspect of his public persona. His ‘everyman’ image, characterized by his choice of attire, has been a notable feature of his political identity. 

Source: Getty Images

However, this preference for casual attire stirred contention on Capitol Hill, leading to the Senate’s eventual decision to formalize an official dress code.

Advertisement

Fetterman’s Journey

Fetterman’s political journey, marked by personal and public challenges, including overcoming a stroke and dealing with clinical depression, has been notable.

Source: Getty Images

His attire has consistently been informal, reflecting a personal style rather than a crafted political statement. This consistency has been observed throughout his political career, presenting an authentic image to the public.

Advertisement

Public Perception

Despite the controversy surrounding his attire, Fetterman’s popularity remains substantial. 

Source: Getty Images

His authenticity, marked by his ‘everyman’ image, has resonated with the public, yielding significant support in elections.

Advertisement

Conspiracy Theories

In the wake of Fetterman’s recovery from a stroke, conspiracy theories arose suggesting he had been replaced by a body double. 

Source: Getty Images

The senator’s improved speech post-recovery fueled these theories. However, the focus of his tenure remained centered on his responsibilities and roles as a senator.

Advertisement

Symbolic Attire

Fetterman’s casual attire, while personal, also represented a departure from traditional norms. This shift was not just in terms of fashion but also indicative of a changing dynamic within the political landscape.

Source: Getty Images

The Senate’s unanimous decision to return to formal attire marked a collective decision to uphold traditional standards.

Advertisement

Formal Dress Code Reinstated

The Senate stood united in the decision to uphold a formal dress code, as evidenced by the unanimous vote. Tradition and formality were reinstated, marking the conclusion of the brief period of relaxed attire. 

Source: Getty Images

Schumer expressed appreciation for the leadership of Senators Manchin and Romney in navigating the conversation and reaching a resolution.

Advertisement

Ongoing Conversations

The debate over Senator Fetterman’s attire, while resolved in the Senate, left lingering questions about the intersection of personal expression and formal traditions in political spaces. 

Source: Getty Images

The attire controversy, although a specific incident, ignited broader conversations that extended beyond the immediate issue, showcasing the complexity of integrating personal and public identities in political life.

Advertisement