Actor Sean Astin and His Mother Finally Find Out The Identity of His Biological Father With DNA Testing

By: Emma Roberts | Last updated: Nov 13, 2023

Raised by Hollywood legend Patty Duke, actor Sean Astin had a successful career in the spotlight. Even with a caring and loving mother, something was still missing—Sean’s biological father.

In his mid-twenties, Sean took a leap of faith and had all three potential fathers take a DNA test. Join us to discover the unbelievable story of how Lord of the Rings, Stranger Things, and The Goonies star Sean Astin and his mother uncovered the truth.

The Mysterious Father of Sean Astin

The curiosity of Sean Astin’s paternity has been a mystery since his childhood. Born to the famed actress Patty Duke, Sean was the center of rumors and speculation from the start. 


Source: Jesse Grant/WireImage

His mother had a few romantic relationships around the time of his birth, which left the question of his biological father’s identity a mystery. Despite the rumors and inquiries, Sean never received any confirmation of his father’s identity, and the truth of his paternity has remained a mystery throughout his life.


Uncovering the Mystery: The Story of Sean Astin 

Born on February 25, 1971, Sean Astin’s birth certificate revealed his mother’s last name—but it wasn’t because she was famous. Academy Award-winning actress Patty Duke was between relationships when she learned she was pregnant with Sean, leaving the identity of his father a mystery. 


Source: Ron Galella Collection/Getty Images

Patty made her best guess as to what day she became pregnant, and Sean was given her last name. Though his father’s identity remained a secret, Sean was raised with love and has gone on to make a name for himself in the entertainment industry.

Parental Woes: Patty's Troubled Love Life

Despite being a teenage celebrity, Patty’s parents had a lot to worry about when it came to her love life. Even though she had just ended her first marriage to Henry Falk, a man 13 years her senior, Patty soon found herself in a new relationship with the 17-year-old Desi Arnaz Jr., son of I Love Lucy’s Lucille Ball and Desi Arnaz. 


Source: Hulton Archive/Getty Images

Despite her parents’ disapproval, Patty went on to become pregnant with Sean. She was able to find happiness in the end, but it wasn’t an easy journey.

Keeping Life Private—Patty's Solution 

When Patty and Desi Jr. had their brief romance, it was over as soon as it started. Being a famous actress and dating another celebrity was shining too much attention and pressure on Patty, who wanted to keep her private life out of the spotlight. 


Source: Henry Gris/Getty Images

Fortunately for her, Michael Tell, a rock music promoter and newspaper publisher, had the perfect answer. Subleasing her apartment, he proposed an interesting solution that would help her keep her love life away from the public eye.

Marriage of Convenience: A 13-Day Fauxmance

Patty had a tenant named Michael Tell. Although they were nearly strangers, he suggested they pretend to be in a relationship to distract the press. Michael believed that this would give Patty the freedom to date whomever she wanted without being hounded by reporters. 

Source: Earl Leaf/Getty Images

Surprisingly, he convinced her to marry him to make the relationship look more genuine. Against all odds, Patty agreed! The two were married for a mere 13 days before getting an annulment. Quite an unconventional romance!


Love Finds a Way: The Remarkable Story of Patty Duke and John Astin 

Patty Duke’s first relationship with a celebrity didn’t have a happy ending, but that didn’t stop her from finding love again. After a brief marriage to Michael Tell, Patty began dating actor John Astin, best known for his role on The Addams Family. 

But there was a hitch—John was still legally married to his first wife. This didn’t stop Patty and John from welcoming their son Sean in February 1971, and two years later, the couple tied the knot.


A Loving Daddy for Little Sean—A Touching Wedding Story 

When Patty and John Astin tied the knot, an 18-month-old Sean was present. While never officially confirmed, John was widely believed to be Sean’s biological father. In one of the most touching moments of the ceremony, Sean looked up at John and exclaimed, “Daddy!”

Source: Facebook

Later, John legally adopted Sean and gave him his last name. With that, Patty and John had a complete family, free from the press and drama that often surrounds celebrity weddings. It was a heartwarming start to their marriage and a wonderful new life for Sean.


A Life Changing Revelation: Patty Duke's Story 

The marriage of Patty Duke and John Astin had been going through a rough patch for the past 13 years, and in 1985, the couple decided to get divorced. This meant that Patty had to figure out where she would live and take custody of her son, Sean. 

Source: Ron Galella/Ron Galella Collection via Getty Images

During this transition, Patty decided it was a good time to reveal a shocking truth to her son—that she did not know who his father was. This news had a life-changing impact on Sean, starting a journey of self-discovery and acceptance.


A Father Found—Sean's Search for Desi Arnaz Jr. 

After hearing a man named Desi Arnaz Jr. might be his father, Sean was determined to meet him. So he reached out, and Desi agreed to the meeting. When the two met, they immediately hit it off, and Sean felt a connection he’d been searching for. 

Source: Nik Wheeler/Corbis via Getty Images

“Desi Arnaz Jr. loves me, and I love him,” Sean said. “We are so close.” He went on to describe Desi as his “second dad,” providing the missing link in his life. Finally, Sean had found his father and a new family that he would cherish forever.


Uncovering the Truth: A 26-Year-Old's Discovery of a Long Lost Relative 

When Sean, 26, received a call from a man claiming to be related to him, he was understandably confused. After all, it is rare to find out in your mid-twenties that you have a family member you never knew about. 

Source: Munawar Hosain/Getty Images

The man was so adamant about his hunch that Sean decided to take a closer look and investigate further. He discovered a truth that would turn his life upside down—and it involved Michael Tell, who Patty Duke married for 13 days before Sean was born.


Unraveling the Mystery: Sean’s Search for the Truth 

Sean was determined to shed some light on his murky past, but his mother was reluctant to provide any details on the matter, and it soon became a topic of interest among the tabloids. 

Source: Aaron Rapoport/Corbis/Getty Images

But when he met Michael Tell, Sean finally had a clue about his father and decided to get to the bottom of it. Was it John Astin or Desi Arnaz Jr.? Or maybe Michael Tell was the answer he had been searching for all along.


A Father Figure in Every Sense: Sean Astin’s Search for His True Parentage 

Despite not having his biological father in his life, Sean Astin has achieved much success in his career and personal life. 

Source: Jeff Kravitz/Getty Images

He has been married to his wife Christine Harrell since 1992 and was raised by two father figures, John Astin and Desi Arnaz Jr. As he strived to answer the question of his true parentage, many have asked if it is really worth the effort to discover something that may not be what he expected. However, Sean Astin remained determined to find his birth father’s identity.


25 Years Later: Sean Astin Discovers His Biological Father 

Sean Astin had been wondering for 25 years who his biological father was, and he had finally had enough. He was determined to get to the bottom of the mystery, and all three possible fathers agreed to a paternity test. 

Source: Carlo Allegri/Getty Images

With the help of DNA testing, the truth was finally revealed after a quarter of a century. John Astin, Desi Arnaz Jr., and Michael Tell took the test, and Sean was ready to learn the results.


A 25-Year Mystery Solved: The Incredible Story of Sean and Michael 

Sean had been searching for answers for 25 years, and a DNA test finally revealed the truth. Michael Tell, a complete stranger to Sean, was his father! Patty Duke, Sean’s mother, was stunned, along with everyone else. 

Source: Barry Brecheisen/WireImage

It turned out that the couple had married as a publicity stunt and never kept in contact but miraculously, Michael was the father. When Sean and Michael stood side by side, their resemblance was obvious. After so many years of not knowing, Sean was finally content and looking forward to getting to know his biological father.


Unlocking the Truth: Patty Duke's 26-Year Struggle 

For 26 long years, Patty Duke carried a burden she didn’t fully understand. The beloved actress was famously open about her bipolar diagnosis and was an advocate for mental health causes.

Source: David S. Holloway/Getty Images

But it was the truth about her son’s biological father that haunted her—something that was equally important for her son Sean Astin to know. Through her struggles, Patty persevered and eventually discovered the answer she and Sean had been searching for. Their story is a testament to the power of determination in the face of adversity.